Safety Index: 11 Long Island Neighborhoods Rated as the Safest in 2024

A low crime rate should be one of your primary concerns when dec iding a Long Island city or neighborhood to settle in. To assist you choose the most secure neighborhood on Long Island, we have compiled a list of the eleven best options.

Kensington

On Long Island, Kensington is where you’ll feel the safest. With a population of 1,226 people, it is a peaceful community in Nassau County, located immediately south of Great Neck. Kensington is a safe, family-oriented town that is often thought of as a New York City bedroom neighborhood because of its excellent schools and low crime rate. Kensington has an 87% lower crime rate than the national average, with 302 offenses per 100,000 population.

Roslyn

When it comes to Long Island neighborhoods, Roslyn is among the safest. You won’t often encounter the quaint small-town vibe that permeates this ancient community on the island’s North Shore. Residents number just under 3,000 in the area. One of the greatest places to live on Long Island is Roslyn, because to its historic roots, rural appeal, and abundance of urban facilities.

Hampstead Harbor and the Robeson-Williams Grist Mill are just two of the many attractions in this region, which is known for its downtown dining and shopping. Roslyn is the perfect spot to discover a sense of security and small-town charm, thanks to its crime rate that is approximately 84% lower than Long Island’s average.

Greenport

Greenport is also among the safest Long Island neighborhoods. Situated on the northern fork of the island, this quaint little town was once the center of a thriving oyster, whaling, maritime construction, and railroad industry. In contrast, the town is now home to only about 2,600 inhabitants and serves as a major attraction for sightseers.

Here locals can unwind by the sea or stroll lazily along one of the numerous boardwalks. For individuals seeking a tranquil lifestyle, this neighborhood offers a crime rate that is around 73% lower than Long Island’s average.

Brookhaven

Among the most secure communities on Long Island, you’ll find the Town of Brookhaven. This area of Suffolk County encompasses fifty unincorporated hamlets and nine villages spread out along the north and south sides of the island.

Brookhaven is a great option for island residents because the crime rate is 69% lower than the Long Island average.

Old Age Serenity: Explore 3 Stunning Places for Budget Retirement in Louisiana

Manhasset

Manhasset is affluent and dangerous all at once. Situated on the inner part of Manhasset Bay, this city is famous for its posh shops and restaurants; in fact, it has been jokingly called the “Rodeo Drive of the East Coast.” Shoppers and foodies travel from far and wide to visit the Miracle Mile, the area’s famous retail strip.

Here locals can enjoy a one-of-a-kind shopping experience at one of sixty foreign boutiques. Manhasset is ideal for affluent families and individuals due to its low crime rate (approximately 65% lower than the island average) and high average home value of $1.9 million.

Great Neck

Great Neck, one of Long Island’s safest cities, is across the water from Manhasset. Those who value proximity to the water’s edge on Long Island will also love this neighborhood. Speculation has it that this neighborhood served as inspiration for F. Scott Fitzgerald’s The Great Gatsby due to its picturesque waterfront vistas and proximity to the North Shore. Great Neck is a highly attractive place because it offers a combination of low-key living and urban conveniences, away from the noise and chaos of the city.

Those who are worried about island safety will be happy to know that Great Neck has a crime rate that is 62% lower than the island average.

Jericho

For individuals who value peace and quiet in a tiny community, Jericho on Long Island is an excellent choice. This city, about 30 miles from Manhattan, located in the middle of Long Island, between Hampstead and Oyster Bay. A little over 13,000 people call this area home, and they all love the tranquility it offers.

Among the several local attractions available to residents of this region are Jericho Commons, Active Kidz Long Island, Old Westbury Gardens, and many more. Jericho is a popular destination for present and future parents due to its significantly lower crime rate (around 62% lower than the island’s average).

Huntington

Another North Shore Long Island neighborhood that is safe to live in is Huntington. The city’s closeness to Manhattan makes it convenient for people to commute into the Big Apple. Huntington, being on the river, served as a crossroads for trade and agriculture in the past. But now it’s a popular destination thanks to its stunning beaches, parks, marinas, and ports, as well as the rest of Long Island.

With a crime rate that is 59% lower than the island-wide average, Huntington remains a relatively safe area on Long Island.

Merrick

If you are looking for a place to call home on the southern tip of the island, Merrick is among the safer choices. Located near New York City and famous for its beaches and pleasant weather, this city provides a suburban feel to its inhabitants.

The crime rate here is around 58% lower than the island average, making it a very safe place to live.

Plainview

Those who like an active lifestyle will find Plainview to be a safe place. This Nassau County city, which was once a rural village, is located around 27 miles from New York City. The approximately 26,000 residents of Plainview make good use of the many parks and other recreational areas in the neighborhood.

Parks like West Hills County Park and Cantiague Park are also located in the neighborhood. There is a general sense of safety for those who enjoy exercising here, as the crime rate is 57% lower than the island average.

West Virginia’s Favourite: 8 Spots for Natural Beauty in the Mountain State

Conclusion

These communities are perfect for families since they provide people with a feeling of safety and tranquility. These communities serve as role models for the rest of the region because of the welcoming atmosphere they’ve created and the safety measures they’ve implemented.

Great schools, recreational opportunities, and a strong feeling of neighborly cooperation contribute to the high standard of living that residents experience. We can learn from these places and work to make Long Island safer for all residents by modeling our actions after them.

Reference: Property Club